I wrote a scanner/lexer to parse my language. Some notes:

  1. I'm scanning files written in UTF-8.
  2. I avoided regex for two reasons:
    • It feels far easier to simply handle codepoints one at a time than to get regex to handle Unicode properly.
    • As far as I can tell, there's no efficient way for me to match a regex starting at a certain position in a string. (The best I can do is O(N) where N is the length of the source string)
  3. I feel like NightScanner is too big, and the cyclomatic complexity of each of the functions is too high. I don't really want to make a "NumberScanner", "SymbolScanner", etc though, because the classes would be really tightly-copuled.


package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.List;

public class NightScanner {

    public ScanResults scan(String text) {
        List<ScanError> errors = new ArrayList<>();
        List<Token> tokens = new ArrayList<>();
        TextIterator textIterator = new TextIterator(text);
        while (textIterator.valid()) {
            int current = textIterator.current();
            if (!Character.isValidCodePoint(current)) {
                errors.add(new ScanError("Invalid code point: " +toString(current), textIterator.getPosition()));
            if (Character.isWhitespace(current)){
            OptionalToken token = matchToken(textIterator);
            if (token.hasError()){
                errors.add(new ScanError(token.getError(), textIterator.getPosition()));
            if (!token.exists()){
                errors.add(new ScanError("Unrecognized code point: "+toString(current), textIterator.getPosition()));
        if (errors.isEmpty()){
            return ScanResults.success(tokens);
        } else {
            return ScanResults.error(errors);

    private String toString(int codePoint){
        return "0x"+Integer.toHexString(codePoint);

    private OptionalToken matchSymbol(int codePoint, TextIterator iterator) {
        switch (codePoint) {
            case Codepoints.LEFT_PARENTHESIS:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.LEFT_PAREN, iterator);
            case Codepoints.RIGHT_PARENTHESIS:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.RIGHT_PAREN, iterator);
            case Codepoints.LEFT_CURLY_BRACKET:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.LEFT_BRACE, iterator);
            case Codepoints.RIGHT_CURLY_BRACKET:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.RIGHT_BRACE, iterator);
            case Codepoints.LEFT_SQUARE_BRACKET:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.LEFT_BRACKET, iterator);
            case Codepoints.RIGHT_SQUARE_BRACKET:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.RIGHT_BRACKET, iterator);
            case Codepoints.LESS_THAN_SIGN:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.LEFT_ANGLE, iterator);
            case Codepoints.GREATER_THAN_SIGN:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.RIGHT_ANGLE, iterator);
            case Codepoints.COMMA:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.COMMA, iterator);
            case Codepoints.FULL_STOP:
                    OptionalToken dotQuestion = matchWord(Codepoints.FULL_STOP, Codepoints.QUESTION_MARK, TokenType.DOT_QUESTION, iterator);
                    if (dotQuestion.exists()) {
                        return dotQuestion;
                    return matchWord(Codepoints.FULL_STOP, TokenType.DOT, iterator);
            case Codepoints.HYPHEN_MINUS:
                    OptionalToken arrow = matchWord(Codepoints.GREATER_THAN_SIGN, TokenType.ARROW, iterator);
                    if (arrow.exists()) {
                        return arrow;
                    if (Character.isDigit(iterator.peek())){
                        return matchNumber(iterator);
                    return matchWord(Codepoints.HYPHEN_MINUS, TokenType.MINUS, iterator);
            case Codepoints.PLUS_SIGN:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.PLUS, iterator);
            case Codepoints.SEMICOLON:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.SEMICOLON, iterator);
            case Codepoints.SOLIDUS:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.SLASH, iterator);
            case Codepoints.ASTERISK:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.ASTERISK, iterator);
            case Codepoints.QUESTION_MARK:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.QUESTION, iterator);
            case Codepoints.VERTICAL_LINE:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.BAR, iterator);
            case Codepoints.AMPERSAND:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.AMPERSAND, iterator);
            case Codepoints.EQUALS_SIGN:
                return OptionalToken.of(TokenType.ASSIGNMENT, iterator);
        return OptionalToken.notFound();

    private void progressIterator(Token token, TextIterator iterator) {
        int length = token.getLexeme().length();
        for (int i = 0; i <= length; i++) {


    private TokenType matchKeyword(String keyword) {
        switch (keyword) {
            case "and":
                return TokenType.AND;
            case "await":
                return TokenType.AWAIT;
            case "break":
                return TokenType.BREAK;
            case "continue":
                return TokenType.CONTINUE;
            case "class":
                return TokenType.CLASS;
            case "else":
                return TokenType.ELSE;
            case "elseif":
                return TokenType.ELSEIF;
            case "end":
                return TokenType.END;
            case "enum":
                return TokenType.ENUM;
            case "eq":
                return TokenType.EQUAL;
            case "false":
                return TokenType.FALSE;
            case "fun":
                return TokenType.FUNCTION;
            case "gt":
                return TokenType.GREATER;
            case "gteq":
                return TokenType.GREATER_EQUAL;
            case "if":
                return TokenType.IF;
            case "let":
                return TokenType.LET;
            case "lt":
                return TokenType.LESS;
            case "lteq":
                return TokenType.LESS_EQUAL;
            case "mut":
                return TokenType.MUTABLE;
            case "neq":
                return TokenType.NOT_EQUAL;
            case "not":
                return TokenType.NOT;
            case "or":
                return TokenType.OR;
            case "panic":
                return TokenType.PANIC;
            case "protocol":
                return TokenType.PROTOCOL;
            case "repeat":
                return TokenType.REPEAT;
            case "return":
                return TokenType.RETURN;
            case "struct":
                return TokenType.STRUCT;
            case "true":
                return TokenType.TRUE;
            case "var":
                return TokenType.VAR;
            case "xor":
                return TokenType.XOR;
            case "yield":
                return TokenType.YIELD;
        return null;

    private OptionalToken matchToken(TextIterator iterator) {
        int currentCodePoint = iterator.current();
        OptionalToken token = matchSymbol(currentCodePoint, iterator);
        if (token.exists()) {
            progressIterator(token.getToken(), iterator);
            return token;
        if (currentCodePoint == Codepoints.QUOTATION_MARK){
            return matchString(iterator);
        if (currentCodePoint == Codepoints.GRAVE_ACCENT){
            return matchRawString(iterator);
        if (Character.isUnicodeIdentifierStart(currentCodePoint) || currentCodePoint == Codepoints.LOW_LINE) {
            int startPosition = iterator.current();
            String identifier = matchIdentifier(iterator);
            TokenType type = matchKeyword(identifier);
            if (type == null) {
                type = TokenType.IDENTIFIER;
            return OptionalToken.of(new Token(type, identifier, startPosition));
        if (Character.isDigit(currentCodePoint)) {
            return matchNumber(iterator);
        return OptionalToken.error("Unrecognized symbol: "+toString(currentCodePoint));

    private OptionalToken matchString(TextIterator iterator){
        StringBuilder stringBuilder = new StringBuilder();
        int startPosition = iterator.getPosition();
        int codePoint = iterator.next();
        while (true){
            if (codePoint == Codepoints.REVERSE_SOLIDUS){
                codePoint = parseEscapeCode(iterator);
                if (codePoint == -1){
                    return OptionalToken.error("Invalid escape code");
                codePoint = iterator.next();
            if (codePoint == Codepoints.LINE_FEED || codePoint == Codepoints.CARRIAGE_RETURN || codePoint == Codepoints.END_OF_TEXT){
                return OptionalToken.error("String not finished");
            if (codePoint == Codepoints.QUOTATION_MARK){
            codePoint = iterator.next();
        return OptionalToken.of(new Token(TokenType.STRING, stringBuilder.toString(), startPosition));

    private OptionalToken matchRawString(TextIterator iterator){
        StringBuilder stringBuilder = new StringBuilder();
        int startPosition = iterator.getPosition();
        int codePoint = iterator.next();
        while (iterator.valid()){
            if (codePoint == Codepoints.GRAVE_ACCENT){
            if (codePoint != Codepoints.CARRIAGE_RETURN){
            codePoint = iterator.next();
        return OptionalToken.of(new Token(TokenType.STRING, stringBuilder.toString(), startPosition));

    private int parseEscapeCode(TextIterator iterator){
        int code = iterator.next();
        switch (code){
            case Codepoints.LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_N004E:
                return Codepoints.LINE_FEED;
            case Codepoints.LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_R0052:
                return Codepoints.CARRIAGE_RETURN;
            case Codepoints.LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_T0054:
                return Codepoints.TAB;
            case Codepoints.LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_U0055:
                return parseUnicode(iterator, 4);
            case Codepoints.LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_U:
                return parseUnicode(iterator, 8);
            case Codepoints.QUOTATION_MARK:
            case Codepoints.APOSTROPHE:
            case Codepoints.REVERSE_SOLIDUS:
                return code;
        return -1;

    private int parseUnicode(TextIterator iterator, int size){
        StringBuilder codepoint = new StringBuilder();
        for (int i = 0; i < size; i++){
        try {
            return Integer.parseInt(codepoint.toString(), 16);
        } catch (NumberFormatException e){
            return -1;

    private String matchIdentifier(TextIterator textIterator) {
        StringBuilder identifierBuilder = new StringBuilder();
        int current = textIterator.next();
        while (true) {
            if (current == Codepoints.END_OF_TEXT || Character.isWhitespace(current)){
            if (Character.isIdentifierIgnorable(current)){
                current = textIterator.next();
            } else if (Character.isUnicodeIdentifierPart(current)) {
                current = textIterator.next();
            } else {
        return identifierBuilder.toString();

    private OptionalToken matchNumber(TextIterator textIterator) {
        StringBuilder numberBuilder = new StringBuilder();
        int start = textIterator.getPosition();
        int codePoint = textIterator.next();
        boolean seenDecimal = false;
        while (true) {
            if (Character.isDigit(codePoint)) {
                codePoint = textIterator.next();

            if (codePoint == Codepoints.LOW_LINE) {
                codePoint = textIterator.next();
                continue; //Ignoring _ so numbers can be readable
            if (codePoint == Codepoints.FULL_STOP) {
                if (seenDecimal) {
                    return OptionalToken.error("Cannot have two decimal points in a number");
                if (!Character.isDigit(textIterator.peek())){
                    return OptionalToken.error("Number cannot end with a decimal point");
                seenDecimal = true;
                codePoint = textIterator.next();
            if (Character.isUnicodeIdentifierStart(codePoint)) {
                StringBuilder stringBuilder = new StringBuilder();
                stringBuilder.append("Invalid character found in number: ");
                return OptionalToken.error(stringBuilder.toString());
            return OptionalToken.of(new Token(TokenType.NUMBER, numberBuilder.toString(), start));

    private OptionalToken matchWord(int part1, TokenType tokenType, TextIterator iterator)
        if (iterator.current() == part1) {
                return OptionalToken.of(tokenType, iterator, 1);
        return OptionalToken.notFound();
    private OptionalToken matchWord(int part1, int part2, TokenType tokenType, TextIterator iterator) {
        if (iterator.current() == part1 && iterator.peek() == part2) {
            return OptionalToken.of(tokenType, iterator, 2);
        return OptionalToken.notFound();



package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

public class TextIterator {

    private int position;
    private int current;
    private final String text;
    public TextIterator(String text) {
        this.text = text;
        current = charAt(0);

    public int getPosition() {
        return position;

    public String getText() {
        return text;

    public int next(){
        int skip = Character.charCount(current);
        position += skip;
        current = charAt(position);
        return current;

    public boolean valid(){
        return position < text.length();

    private int charAt(int position){
        if (position >= text.length()){
            return '\03';
        return text.codePointAt(position);

    public int peek(){
        return charAt(Character.charCount(current) + position);

    public int current(){
        return current;


The following code doesn't need review (AFIAK), its more here to help you test/run my code:

My testing code:

package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

import org.testng.Assert;
import org.testng.annotations.DataProvider;
import org.testng.annotations.Test;

import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.Iterator;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.stream.Collectors;

public class ScannerTest {

    private final NightScanner scanner;

    public ScannerTest() {
        this.scanner = new NightScanner();

    public void emptyString() {
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan("");

    @DataProvider(name = "numbers")
    public Object[][] numberData() {
        return new Object[][]{

    @Test(dataProvider = "numbers")
    public void numbers(String number) {
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan(number);
        String expected = number.replaceAll("_", "");
        assertTokens(results, expected);
        assertTokenTypes(results, TokenType.NUMBER);

    @DataProvider(name = "invalidNumbers")
    public Object[][] invalidNumberData() {
        return new Object[][]{

    @Test(dataProvider = "invalidNumbers")
    public void invalidNumbers(String invalid) {
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan(invalid);

    @DataProvider(name = "identifiers")
    public Object[][] identifierData(){
        return new Object[][]{

    @Test(dataProvider = "identifiers")
    public void identifiers(String identifier){
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan(identifier);
        assertTokenTypes(results, TokenType.IDENTIFIER);
        assertTokens(results, identifier);

    @DataProvider(name = "ignorables")
    public Object[][] ignorableData(){
        return new Object[][]{
                {"a\u0000\u0001\u0002\u0004\u0005\u0006\u0007\u0008b"},// Intentionally skip \u0003

    @Test(dataProvider = "ignorables")
    public void identifierIgnores(String ignorable){
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan(ignorable);
        assertTokenTypes(results, TokenType.IDENTIFIER);
        assertTokens(results, "ab");

    public Iterator<Object[]> stringData(){
        List<Object[]> data = new ArrayList<>();
        String[] literals = new String[] {
        for (String literal : literals) {
            data.add(new Object[]{
                    "\"" + literal + "\"", literal
            data.add(new Object[]{
                    "`" + literal + "`", literal
        data.add(new Object[]{"\"`\"", "`"});
        data.add(new Object[]{"`\"`", "\""});
        String[][] escapes = new String[][]{
                {"\\n", "\n"},
                {"\\\\", "\\"},
                {"\\u0035", "5"},
                {"\\U0001D49E", "\uD835\uDC9E"},
                {"\\\"", "\""},
                {"\\'", "'"}
        for (String[] escape: escapes){
           data.add(new Object[]{"\""+escape[0]+"\"", escape[1]});
        for (String[] escape: escapes){
            data.add(new Object[]{"`"+escape[1]+"`", escape[1]});
        data.add(new Object[]{"\"\\r\"", "\r"});
        data.add(new Object[]{"`\r`", ""});
        return data.iterator();

    @Test(dataProvider = "strings")
    public void strings(String string, String match){
        ScanResults results = scanner.scan(string);
        assertTokenTypes(results, TokenType.STRING);
        assertTokens(results, match);

    private void assertTokens(ScanResults results, String... tokens) {
        assertTokensLength(results, tokens.length);
        for (int i = 0; i < tokens.length; i++) {
            Assert.assertEquals(results.getTokens().get(i).getLexeme(), tokens[i], "Wrong token contents");

    private void assertTokenTypes(ScanResults results, TokenType... tokens) {
        assertTokensLength(results, tokens.length);
        for (int i = 0; i < tokens.length; i++) {
            Assert.assertEquals(results.getTokens().get(i).getTokenType(), tokens[i], "Wrong token type");

    private void assertTokensLength(ScanResults results, int length) {
        Assert.assertEquals(results.getTokens().size(), length, "Wrong number of tokens returned");

    private void assertNoErrors(ScanResults scanResults) {
        Assert.assertTrue(scanResults.getErrors().isEmpty(), "Scanner errors:" + scanResults.getErrors().stream().map(ScanError::getMessage).collect(Collectors.joining()));

    private void assertError(ScanResults scanResults) {
        assertErrors(scanResults, 1);

    private void assertErrors(ScanResults scanResults, int count) {
        Assert.assertFalse(scanResults.isSuccess(), "No errors returned");
        Assert.assertEquals(scanResults.getErrors().size(), count, "Wrong number of errors returned");



package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

@SuppressWarnings({"unused", "WeakerAccess"})
public class Codepoints {
    private Codepoints(){}
    public final static int END_OF_TEXT = 0x0003;
    public final static int BELL = 0x0007;
    public final static int BACKSPACE = 0x0008;
    public final static int TAB = 0x0009;
    public final static int LINE_FEED = 0x000A;
    public final static int FORM_FEED = 0x000C;
    public final static int CARRIAGE_RETURN = 0x000D;
    public final static int SPACE = 0x0020;
    public final static int EXCLAMATION_MARK = 0x0021;
    public final static int QUOTATION_MARK = 0x0022;
    public final static int NUMBER_SIGN = 0x0023;
    public final static int DOLLAR_SIGN = 0x0024;
    public final static int PERCENT_SIGN = 0x0025;
    public final static int AMPERSAND = 0x0026;
    public final static int APOSTROPHE = 0x0027;
    public final static int LEFT_PARENTHESIS = 0x0028;
    public final static int RIGHT_PARENTHESIS = 0x0029;
    public final static int ASTERISK = 0x002A;
    public final static int PLUS_SIGN = 0x002B;
    public final static int COMMA = 0x002C;
    public final static int HYPHEN_MINUS = 0x002D;
    public final static int FULL_STOP = 0x002E;
    public final static int SOLIDUS = 0x002F;
    public final static int DIGIT_ZERO = 0x0030;
    public final static int DIGIT_ONE = 0x0031;
    public final static int DIGIT_TWO = 0x0032;
    public final static int DIGIT_THREE = 0x0033;
    public final static int DIGIT_FOUR = 0x0034;
    public final static int DIGIT_FIVE = 0x0035;
    public final static int DIGIT_SIX = 0x0036;
    public final static int DIGIT_SEVEN = 0x0037;
    public final static int DIGIT_EIGHT = 0x0038;
    public final static int DIGIT_NINE = 0x0039;
    public final static int COLON = 0x003A;
    public final static int SEMICOLON = 0x003B;
    public final static int LESS_THAN_SIGN = 0x003C;
    public final static int EQUALS_SIGN = 0x003D;
    public final static int GREATER_THAN_SIGN = 0x003E;
    public final static int QUESTION_MARK = 0x003F;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_A = 0x0041;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_B = 0x0042;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_C = 0x0043;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_D = 0x0044;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_E = 0x0045;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_F = 0x0046;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_G = 0x0047;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_H = 0x0048;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_I = 0x0049;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_J = 0x004A;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_K = 0x004B;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_L = 0x004C;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_M = 0x004D;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_N = 0x004E;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_O = 0x004F;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_P = 0x0050;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_Q = 0x0051;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_R = 0x0052;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_S = 0x0053;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_T = 0x0054;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_U = 0x0055;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_V = 0x0056;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_W = 0x0057;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_X = 0x0058;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_Y = 0x0059;
    public final static int LATIN_CAPITAL_LETTER_Z = 0x005A;
    public final static int LEFT_SQUARE_BRACKET = 0x005B;
    public final static int REVERSE_SOLIDUS = 0x005C;
    public final static int RIGHT_SQUARE_BRACKET = 0x005D;
    public final static int CIRCUMFLEX_ACCENT = 0x005E;
    public final static int LOW_LINE = 0x005F;
    public final static int GRAVE_ACCENT = 0x0060;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_A0041 = 0x0061;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_B0042 = 0x0062;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_C0043 = 0x0063;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_D0044 = 0x0064;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_E0045 = 0x0065;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_F0046 = 0x0066;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_G0047 = 0x0067;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_H0048 = 0x0068;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_I0049 = 0x0069;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_J004A = 0x006A;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_K004B = 0x006B;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_L004C = 0x006C;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_M004D = 0x006D;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_N004E = 0x006E;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_O004F = 0x006F;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_P0050 = 0x0070;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_Q0051 = 0x0071;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_R0052 = 0x0072;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_S0053 = 0x0073;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_T0054 = 0x0074;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_U0055 = 0x0075;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_V0056 = 0x0076;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_W0057 = 0x0077;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_X0058 = 0x0078;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_Y0059 = 0x0079;
    public final static int LATIN_SMALL_LETTER_Z005A = 0x007A;
    public final static int LEFT_CURLY_BRACKET = 0x007B;
    public final static int VERTICAL_LINE = 0x007C;
    public final static int RIGHT_CURLY_BRACKET = 0x007D;
    public final static int TILDE = 0x007E;
    public final static int NO_BREAK_SPACE = 0x00A0;
    public final static int INVERTED_EXCLAMATION_MARK = 0x00A1;
    public final static int CENT_SIGN = 0x00A2;
    public final static int POUND_SIGN = 0x00A3;
    public final static int CURRENCY_SIGN = 0x00A4;


package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

public class OptionalToken {
    private final Token token;
    private final String error;
    private OptionalToken(Token token, String error){
        this.token = token;
        this.error = error;

    public String getError() {
        return error;

    public Token getToken() {
        return token;

    public boolean exists(){
        return token != null;

    public boolean hasError(){
        return error != null;

    public static OptionalToken notFound(){
        return new OptionalToken(null, null);

    public static OptionalToken error(String error){
        return new OptionalToken(null, error);

    public static OptionalToken of(TokenType tokenType, TextIterator iterator){
        return of(tokenType, iterator, 1);

    public static OptionalToken of(TokenType tokenType, TextIterator iterator, int length){
        int position = iterator.getPosition();
        return of(
                new Token(tokenType, iterator.getText().substring(position, position+length), position)
    public static OptionalToken of(Token token){
        return new OptionalToken(token, null);



package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

public class Token {   

    private final TokenType tokenType;
    private final String lexeme;
    private final int characterPosition;

    public Token(TokenType tokenType, String lexeme, int characterPosition) {
        this.tokenType = tokenType;
        this.lexeme = lexeme;
        this.characterPosition = characterPosition;

    public TokenType getTokenType() {
        return tokenType;

    public String getLexeme() {
        return lexeme;

    public int getCharacterPosition() {
        return characterPosition;



package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

public enum TokenType {

    // Operators

    // Comparators


    // Structures

    // Control Flow

    // Mod  ifiers

    // Literals



package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

import java.util.ArrayList;
import java.util.List;

public class ScanResults {

    private final List<Token> tokens;
    private final List<ScanError> errors;

    private ScanResults(List<Token> tokens, List<ScanError> errors) {
        this.tokens = tokens;
        this.errors = errors;

    public static ScanResults success(List<Token> tokens){
        return new ScanResults(tokens, new ArrayList<>());

    public static ScanResults error(List<ScanError> errors){
        return new ScanResults(new ArrayList<>(), errors);

    public List<Token> getTokens() {
        return tokens;

    public List<ScanError> getErrors() {
        return errors;

    public boolean isSuccess(){
        return errors == null;


package com.nmerrill.night.parsing;

public class ScanError {
    private final String message;
    private final int position;

    public ScanError(String message, int position) {
        this.message = message;
        this.position = position;
    public String getMessage() {
        return message;
    public int getPosition(){
        return position;

    public String toString() {
        return message;
  • \$\begingroup\$ I get the feeling that you may have a much easier start with lexing, if you'd tokenize your input stream into words instead of working on the character level... \$\endgroup\$ – Vogel612 Nov 6 '17 at 10:25
  • 1
    \$\begingroup\$ Isn't tokenization the purpose of lexing? \$\endgroup\$ – Nathan Merrill Nov 6 '17 at 11:12
  1. Cyclomatic complexity in NightScanner

    You can reduce cyclomatic complexity (at cost of some memory overhead, usually acceptable) by replacing switch with map lookups:

    private static final Map<Integer, Codepoints> codePointMap = buildCodePointMap();
    // Alternative: build Map with Map.of(K1,V1, K2,V2, ...) in java 9
    private static Map<Integer, TokenType> buildCodePointMap() {
        map.put(Codepoints.AMPERSAND, TokenType.AMPERSAND);
        map.put(Codepoints.EQUALS_SIGN, TokenType.ASSIGNMENT);
        return map;
    private OptionalToken matchSymbol(int codePoint, TextIterator iterator) {
        TokenType result = symbolMap.get(codePoint);
        return result != null ? OptionalToken.of(result, iterator) : matchSymbolEdgeCase(codePoint, TextIterator);
        // let matchSymbolEdgeCase deal with things like FULL_STOP or no match

    You could then refactor the map out to a separate class, allowing NightScanner to delegate those details instead of doing everything.

    For the complexity in scan(String text), it should be possible to extract the textIterator.next() outside of the if statements and get rid of the continue statements. Roughly, something like this may work in the while:

    boolean err = false;
    //... existing if statements
    if (err) textIterator.next();
    else tokens.add(token.getToken());

    Then probably just return new ScanResults(tokens, errors), modify ScanResults so that the lists are never null, and then change isSuccess() to return errors.isEmpty().

  2. Issues with ScanResults and OptionalToken

    Actually, ScanResults currently seems like a slightly unnecessary abstraction (some kind of exception strategy might be better), but it can stay for now.

    If possible, OptionalToken shouldn't manage both tokens and errors. Errors could be addressed in a custom Exception class, and then it may be possible to remove OptionalToken and use a standard Optional<Token>.

  3. BTW, it's perfectly good to refactor to NumberScanner, SymbolScanner, etc. Just keep them package scope and let them interact via package-visibility methods. NightScanner would still be the only one with public methods. Coupling is usually fine if a class evolves into multiple related classes. Usually the horror stories are across different packages, bidirectional coupling, or dependency.getThis().getThat()...

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.