I have a big (50k*150k) matrix with co-occurrences of nouns (rows) and adjectives (columns). As most nouns don't co-occurr with most adjectives, this matrix is very sparse, >99.9%, so I'm using the CSR format. For every pair of nouns I need to calculate the Jason-Shannon Divergence to asses how similar the co-occurrence distributions with all adjectives are between each pair. I have sixteen cores I can use, so I run the calculations in parallel, such that each core processes every sixteenth noun.

It's not going very fast and I'm wondering whether there's a faster way to do this.

from __future__ import division
from multiprocessing import Pool
from scipy.stats import entropy
import codecs
import os
import scipy
import scipy.sparse

# --- data & parameters--- #
frequenciesAdjectives = codecs.open('frequencies.txt', 'r', 'utf-8')
results = codecs.open('results.txt', 'w', 'utf-8')
temporaryFilesPath = "/temp/"
cores = 16

# --- functions --- #

# calculate jensen shannon divergence
def JSD(p, q):
    p = p
    q = q
    m = 0.5 * (p+q)
    jsd = 0.5 * (entropy(p, m) + entropy(q, m))
    return jsd

# calculate JSD for every i-th noun with every other noun and write to temp file, where i is the number of cores used, and return filepath
def getJSDs(n):
    # open temporary file
    filename = "temp"+str(n).zfill(2)
    fullpath = temporaryFilesPath+filename
    temp = codecs.open(fullpath, "w", "utf-8")

    # shortcut write function
    tempwrite = temp.write

    # calculate JSD for each noun pair and write to temporary file
    for index, noun1 in enumerate(nouns[n::cores]):
        index = index*cores+n
        first = sparseMatrix.getrow(index).toarray()[0]
        for index2, noun2 in enumerate(nouns[index:]):
            index2 += index
            second = sparseMatrix.getrow(index2).toarray()[0]
            divergence = JSD(first, second)

    return fullpath

# --- processing --- #

# set up parameter variables for sparse matrix
nouns = []
adjectiveIDs = {}     # column id of each adjective in matrix
frequencies = []     # non-zero entries in matrix
positions = []         # column id of frequency in corresponding position in "frequencies"
indices = [0]         # frequencies[indices[i]:indices[i+]] = non-zero entries of line i of matrix

# ignore file header

# incrementally get sparse matrix parameters (turn frequencies into probabilites)
for line in frequenciesAdjectives:
    line = line.strip().lower().split("\t")
    noun = line[0]
    adjectiveList = [pair.split(" ") for pair in line[2:]]
        total = sum([int(frequency) for _,frequency in adjectiveList])
    for pair in adjectiveList:
        adjective, frequency = pair
                probability = int(frequency)/total
        position = adjectiveIDs.setdefault(adjective, len(adjectiveIDs))

# turn lists into arrays
frequencies = scipy.array(frequencies)
positions = scipy.array(positions)
indices = scipy.array(indices)

# create sparse matrix from parameter arrays and delete arrays
sparseMatrix = scipy.sparse.csr_matrix((frequencies, positions, indices), shape=(len(nouns), len(adjectiveIDs)))
del frequencies, positions, indices, adjectiveIDs

# calculate JSDs in parallel and get list of temporary files
pool = Pool()
tempFiles = pool.map(getJSDs, range(cores))

# shortcut results.write and write header
resultswrite = results.write

# combine temporary files into results file and delete
for path in tempFiles:
    tempfile = codecs.open(path, "r", "utf-8")
    for line in tempfile:

The format of the file from which I read in the frequencies is this:


I can't use the dense matrix format, because that uses up all of the RAM. I doubt I can get the entropy function to run faster than SciPy - I tried using a for loop and numba, but it didn't come out faster and I don't know any C. I don't really know parallel computing, so I bet my way of using pool.map isn't optimal. Would it maybe be faster if I copied the global matrix variable into a local variable for each function?


1 Answer 1


I rewrote the entire thing, now it's two orders of magnitude (500x or so!) faster.

Key changes include:

  • Using a list of tuples (noun, adjectiveDictionary) instead of the sparse matrix and dropping the 0 elements completely
  • Using math.log instead of scipy.log (huge difference!)
  • Switching from Python 2 to Python 3
  • Not dividing the tasks up manually, instead using a generator and the queue that comes with imap_unordered, for which it was crucial to find the right chunksize.


from multiprocessing import Pool
from collections import Counter
from math import log2
# from numba import jit

# --- data & parameters--- #
frequenciesAdjectives = open('/home/christian/results/gender/frequenciesAdjectivesGivenNouns_UK.txt', 'r')
results = open('/home/christian/results/gender/JensenShannonDivergences_ukWaC.txt', 'w')
cores = 16

# --- functions --- #
# calculates Jason-Shannon Divergence from tuple of two nouns and their associated adjective probabilities in dictionaries p and q
def JSD(nounTuple):
    noun1, noun2, p, q = nounTuple
    jsd = 0.0
    m = p + q
    for key in m:
        m_key = 0.5 * m[key]
        if key in p:
            p_key = p[key]
            jsd += 0.5 * p_key * log2(p_key/m_key)
        if key in q:
            q_key = q[key]
            jsd += 0.5 * q_key * log2(q_key/m_key)
    return noun1, noun2, jsd

def jobGenerator(tuples):
    for index, (noun, adjectives) in enumerate(tuples):
        for noun2, adjectives2 in tuples[index:]:
            yield noun, noun2, adjectives, adjectives2

# --- processing --- #
# ignore header

# make list of tuples of nouns and dictionaries containing their preceding adjective frequencies
nounAdjectives = []
for line in frequenciesAdjectives:
    adjectives = Counter()
    line = line.strip().lower().split("\t")
    noun = line[0]
    adjectiveList = [pair.split(" ") for pair in line[2:]]
    frequencySum = sum(int(frequency) for _, frequency in adjectiveList)
    for adjective, frequency in adjectiveList:
        probability = int(frequency)/frequencySum
        adjectives[adjective] = probability
    nounAdjectives.append((noun, adjectives))

# make generator of (noun, noun2, adjectives, adjectives2)-tuples
jobs = jobGenerator(nounAdjectives)

# shortcut results.write and write header
resultswrite = results.write

# calculate JSDs in parallel and write to file
pool = Pool(cores)
for noun1, noun2, jsd in pool.imap_unordered(JSD, jobs, chunksize=500000):

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.