I have as input a potentially large CSV file (gzip compressed) with a known structure. I don't know in advance the size of this file, but let's say it can't fit in memory. The rows in this CSV are ordered like the following:

key1, …other fields

They are ordered by the value in the first column (let's call it key), but it is unknown how many rows are there for each distinct key. I need to scan the whole file and process only the first N rows matching each key (there could be more than N rows for some of the keys). These N rows per key can be processed in memory.

I came up with this code, but I don't like it very much. It is a bit messy:

import gzip

def process_rows(key rows):    
    print(f'Processed rows for key {key}')

def main(file_path, N=1000):    
    with gzip.GzipFile(filename=file_path) as file:
        curr_key = None
        rows_to_process = []

        for line in file:
            line = line.decode().strip()

            if len(line) == 0:

            fields = line.split(',')
            [key, field2, field3] = fields

            if curr_key is not None:
                if curr_key != key or (len(rows_to_process) > 0 and len(rows_to_process) % N == 0):                    
                    process_rows(key, rows_to_process)

                    # Find next key if needed
                    while curr_key == key:
                        line = next(file, None)

                        if line is None:
                            return  # End of file, exit

                        line = line.decode().strip()

                        if len(line) < 1:

                        fields = line.split(',')
                        [key, field2, field3] = fields

                    print('Found next key', key)

                    # Reset rows to process
                    rows_to_process = []

            curr_key = key
            rows_to_process.append([key, field2, field3])

        # Flush trailing data
        if (len(rows_to_process) > 0):
            process_rows(key, rows_to_process)

Is there a cleaner way to do this?


1 Answer 1


Minor niggles

Testing len() > 0 is over-wordy. If we want to test whether a string or list is non-empty, its truthiness directly indicates that (see below, if not line:).

Structure and design

There's a lot in main(), and it doesn't lend itself to unit-testing very well. I would split its responsibilities, probably splitting into a generator that emits each line as an array (or more likely, a tuple) of fields, and a consumer that batches your N rows:

def rows(input):
    Generator function yielding the first three fields of each line of input.
    for line in input:
        line = line.decode().strip()
        if not line:
        fields = line.split(',') # assumes no quoted ',' in fields
        yield fields[0:2]

For the grouping of up to N lines, we can take advantage of the standard library functions in itertools to eliminate most of the logic you wrote.

Specifically, itertools.groupby() to get an iterator for each group of rows, and itertools.islice() to take the first N elements from each of those:

import gzip
import itertools
import operator

def main(file_path, N=1000, func=process_rows):
    groups = itertools.groupby(rows(gzip.GzipFile(filename=file_path)),
    for (key, values) in groups:
        func(key, itertools.islice(values, N))

I tested the code with a modified process function:

def process_rows(key, rows):    
    print(f'Processed {len(list(rows))} row(s) for key {key}')

and this input:


The output is:

Processed 3 row(s) for key alpha
Processed 1 row(s) for key beta
Processed 3 row(s) for key gamma
  • 2
    \$\begingroup\$ Testing len() > 0 might also be considered good PEP0020 (explicit is better than implicit). \$\endgroup\$
    – Reinderien
    Commented Oct 15, 2022 at 13:02

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.