I already posted this on Stack Overflow, but someone suggested to post it to Code Review instead.

I am creating an Android app that draws to the canvas. For this, I have defined rectangular screenareas that I want to draw to the canvas. As I am always drawing a fixed set of screenareas, I was thinking of using Enum (as Enum is designed for fixed sets).

Here is my enum:

public enum LayoutEnum {
            new ScreenArea(
                new Rect(
            new ScreenArea (
                    new Rect(
                            (int) (0.3 * FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getArea().width()),
                            (int) (0.3 * FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getArea().width()),
                            (int) (FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getArea().width() - 0.3 * FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getArea().width()),
                            (int) (0.7 * FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getArea().width())),

    private ScreenArea screenArea;

    LayoutEnum(ScreenArea screenArea) {
        this.screenArea = screenArea;

    public ScreenArea getScreenArea() {
        return screenArea;

ScreenArea is a simple class that holds a Rect and a Paint and contains a draw method (and some getters and setters).

The question I have, is: is this a good approach? On one hand I am working with a fixed set of variables. On the other hand, these variables are mutable and I can change their attributes (e.g., using the getters and setters). For example, I can call FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().getPaint().setColor(Color.BLUE)

When you look at Enum it says it is

a special data type that enables for a variable to be a set of predefined constant

So I do have a fixed set, it is predefined, but not necessarily constant.

My original approach was to define a class called Layout which contained a HashMap of Screenarea's. In that case, I was using e.g., Layout.get("fullscreen").draw(canvas) to draw the screenarea to the canvas. In this new approach I am using e.g., FULLSCREEN.getScreenArea().draw(canvas).

One of the reasons I would like to switch is to introduce a typesafe solution. Of course, it would also be possible to switch from a HashMap to an EnumMap and store the names of my screenareas in an Enum.

Hope you can point me in the right direction: a direction that not only works (the above is already working) but is also acceptable and doesn't smell.


Enums are meant to be immutable. I'd go with the EnumMap.

| improve this answer | |
  • \$\begingroup\$ That is what I am working on right now :) \$\endgroup\$ – MWB Oct 12 '18 at 11:54

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.