Code Review Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for peer programmer code reviews. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

I'm trying to write a simple triplestore in Common Lisp that will store triples in the form subject-predicate-object. The code is inspired by the book "Programming the Semantic Web".

(defvar triplestore-graph (make-hash-table))

(defun triplestore-init ()
  (puthash :spo (make-hash-table) triplestore-graph)
  (puthash :pos (make-hash-table) triplestore-graph)
  (puthash :osp (make-hash-table) triplestore-graph))

(defun triplestore-add (s p o)
  (triplestore-add-to-index :spo s p o)
  (triplestore-add-to-index :pos p o s)
  (triplestore-add-to-index :osp o s p))

(defun triplestore-add-to-index (index a b c)
  (let ((index (gethash index triplestore-graph)))
    (cond ((not (gethash a index))
           (let ((tmp (make-hash-table)))
             (puthash a
                        (puthash b
                                 (list c)
          ((not (gethash b (gethash a index)))
           (puthash b
                    (list c)
                    (gethash a index)))
           (nconc (list c)
                  (gethash b
                           (gethash a index)))))))

Here (puthash k v table) is defined as (setf (gethash k table) v). The code above is roughly equivalent to the Python code:

graph = {}

def init(graph):
    graph['_spo'] = {}
    graph['_pos'] = {}
    graph['_osp'] = {}

def add(graph, (s, p, o)):
    _addToIndex(graph['_spo'], s, p, o)
    _addToIndex(graph['_pos'], p, o, s)
    _addToIndex(graph['_osp'], o, s, p)

def _addToIndex(index, a, b, c):
    if a not in index:
        index[a] = {b: set([c])}
    elif b not in index[a]:
        index[a][b] = set([c])

How can i improve readability and elegantness of the Common Lisp code? I'm mainly concerned that operations with hash-tables are verbose comparing to Python's equivalents. Are there macros for hash-table handling, for example?

share|improve this question
up vote 5 down vote accepted

First of all, I suggest that you use a structure instead of a hash table when you know that the table will only have 3 elements; this improves both readability and performance:

(defstruct triplestore-graph 
  (spo (make-hash-table))
  (pos (make-hash-table))
  (osp (make-hash-table)))
(defvar *triplestore-graph* (make-triplestore-graph))

Next, there is no puthash in Common Lisp, use (setf gethash) instead.

Finally, I would modify the code like this:

(defun triplestore-add (s p o)
  (triplestore-add-to-index (triplestore-graph-spo *triplestore-graph*) s p o)
  (triplestore-add-to-index (triplestore-graph-pos *triplestore-graph*) p o s)
  (triplestore-add-to-index (triplestore-graph-osp *triplestore-graph*) o p s)) ; o s p?!

(defun triplestore-add-to-index (index a b c)
  (let ((at (gethash a index)))
    (if at
        (pushnew c (gethash b at))
        (setf (gethash a index)
              (let ((tmp (make-hash-table)))
                (setf (gethash b tmp) (list c))
share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.